On the eve of her retirement from McGill University in 2010, historian Andrée Lévesque had a vision: to create a different kind of archive, one which collected the personal letters, diaries, and autobiographies of ‘ordinary’ Quebecers.
“After all these years, I’m still looking for another way to describe it, nobody’s ordinary,” she told me when we spoke over Zoom earlier this spring. “I was looking for the records of people who are not known, people whose personal papers could not be accepted by the national archives in Quebec or Ottawa.”
The Archives Passe-Mémoire (APM) started modestly enough with the materials from one family stored in the corner of a room in her home. Fifteen years on, the collection has now taken over her entire house and encompasses over a hundred separate fonds; some are for one individual and others are for families.
“We have a very large collection from a woman who was born in Lebanon and immigrated in Quebec City when she was about 30 or something, and lived till she was 96 and kept her diary from the age of 16 to 90. That was a bonanza when we got it.”
What prompted her to undertake on a project as ambitious in scope as this? “It all started with a book,” she said. “I came across Alain Corbin’s The Life of an Unknown. Corbin was looking for a new way to tell history. He went to a small village near his home and opened the page for registered births in 1789 and put his finger on a birth. This random gesture led him to recreate the life of Louis-Francois Pinagot, a forester and clog maker. And I thought, it would be nice to have had personal archives to write that story, because Corbin didn’t have any.”
In addition, she was prompted to act quickly by the advent of email. “It was the realisation that I am a part of the last generation of people who have written letters, who have written a diary with a pen and paper in a book. All that is almost lost now. With email, people stopped writing letters on paper. Digital records can easily disappear. When I changed computers, I lost half my emails. Paper is what remains.”
“We have lots of love letters but what’s wonderful is when you have both sides of the correspondence, his and hers. We have one collection where he writes on blue paper, and she writes on pink paper.”
So, in 2010, with a little grant money, and some fellow historians she founded the archive centre. The project took off with coverage from Radio-Canada and Québec magazines like L’Actualité: “People would phone us because their grandmother died and they found her diary in the bottom of a closet,” Lévesque said. “And the grandchildren didn’t know what to do with that.”
Material also came from less likely places. “A janitor got in touch with us, saying he had found a notebook by the garbage. It turned out to be the last volume, number 11, of a diary kept by a Montreal journalist between the 1930s and the 1950s. Unfortunately this volume is all we have.”
“People talk about their children, their delivery, how this is really going to be the last one. And about the midwife coming if there’s no doctor. I think about a poor woman on the north coast who keeps having children.”
The archives cover a broad range of experiences and subjects, although Lévesque admits that trips to Paris and the Eiffel Tower are overrepresented. “People talk about their children, about the birthing experience, but they tend to be discreet about sex. Gay men are the exception. Gay men will write about coming to Montreal to cruise, cruising by the port and ending up in bed. Women are much more reticent.”
From the joy of falling in love to the agony of terminal illness, the personal papers lay bare the lives of the chroniclers. Lévesque told me about a diary in the archives kept in the early eighties by a man dying of AIDs. “It’s like a descent into hell,” Lévesque said. “The man died before the medicine that could have saved his life became available.”
Subscribe to my Blog
Everyone who donates material signs a contract attesting that the material donated is real, not fictional, and that the documents will be put at the disposal of researchers. People are free to use a pseudonym to protect their privacy. Donors can also place restrictions on how the material can be viewed, and these restrictions can vary. One donor stipulated that only the immediate family could access it. Someone else said that anyone could read it except their family.
“A student who was researching a paper on women at Expo came to visit the archives. Anyone who wrote in 1967, 1968 is bound to have mentioned Expo. We showed her material that had all kinds of people writing about Expo, people coming from out of town and going to Dupri to change their clothes, to dress up for Expo.”
“I remember a gay man in his late 70s who lived in a remote village. He contacted us. He felt someone should have his diary, but he didn’t know who was going to be interested in it. I told him that historians now do social history, cultural history, history of sexuality. Then a visiting American professor working on a gay history project found the diary in the archive and went to see him.”
The archive is a valuable resource for writers, including one from Belgium. “She was writing a novel, which takes place partly in Québec and she wanted to know testimonies of how women lived and what they did in Montreal in 1920s, the experience of dating.” The archives were able to give her a sense of what it was like to be alive a century ago.
“We can’t take everything. There was a university professor who gave us all his lecture notes and all his articles off print. Fortunately, he had his diary when he was in college, and that was wonderful.”
Lévesque has won awards for biographies she has written about Quebec women. I wondered if the material that has found its way into the archives had ever tempted her to write another?
“Well, there is a woman who sent us 258 notebooks of 250 pages each that she kept in 1970s. This is someone who has very little education, who was on welfare most of the time. She tells you exactly how she cheats on welfare, how she steals her coat from a shop, what she ate for breakfast. She’s an obsessive writer. I haven’t read all of what she wrote but I recently picked one of her many notebooks and in it she describes how she found a translation of Wuthering Heights in a secondhand bookshop in northern Montreal and bought it. When I find gems like that, I only wish I had more time.”
“A decorator gave us his diary he’s written his first day in Paris in 1968. He’s 20 years old, and he arrives there to study design. He gets a piece of cheese and a baguette and a bottle of wine and he’s looking out his window. And he’s never been so happy in his life.”.
As far as Lévesque knows, the APM is the only archive of its kind in Canada. “In Europe, there are many of these kinds of archives, but they tend to be associations, with members. We have retired archivists working with us and so the APM tends to be more professionally managed.”
And while the APM focuses on francophone Quebecers, Lévesque says they would like to have more artifacts from people of other ethnic backgrounds, and from immigrants. “We have some from Lebanese Canadians, and a couple of anglophones but that is not nearly enough.”
“I think that these wonderful writings give us a much richer and more vivid sense of people’s lives and the times they lived in.”
Andrée Lévesque was my thesis advisor. In June 1990, she took a group of us to the Berkshire Women’s History Conference 1990. I’m on the extreme left, Andrée the extreme right.
“With almost nothing in her hands, Andrée Lévesque manages to bring a whole chapter of Quebec history to life before the reader’s eyes, in a kind of narrative magic where she wraps her subject in a multi-coloured tapestry.” – Le Devoir.
As we approached National Canadian Film Day, I found myself musing on what it means to be a filmmaker and a history buff, particularly after a friend invited me to give a guest lecture to his class. Professor Donald Wright teaches a course called “Pierre Trudeau’s Canada” at the University of New Brunswick. He was screening my documentary Just Watch Me: Trudeau and the ‘70s Generation and wanted me to answer his students’ questions about Trudeau, bilingualism, and the film itself.
The film came out in 1999, and where it once struck a chord with contemporary audiences, it is now very much a historical artifact. Just Watch Me spoke to a generation who had grown up with Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau’s vision of a bilingual and multicultural Canada that survived two referenda that could well have broken up the country. Could it still speak to young audiences almost a quarter of a century later?
Shooting Just Watch Me in Iqaluit in 1998. It was very cold, however, the light was extraordinarily beautiful.
“Twenty-five years after the fact, Just Watch Me is now a primary source,” Don told me. “And like any primary source, it can be read for what it can tell us about the past: in this case, English Canada’s search for an identity and Pierre Trudeau’s place in the English Canadian imagination. For the student, a documentary brings the past to life. It’s not just people’s words on a page; its facial expressions, mannerisms, accents. These are real people struggling with the 1995 referendum and the end of a dream they grew up on. It makes the historical period relatable in a way that books just don’t.”
President of the Canadian Historical Association, Professor Donald Wright has won numerous teaching awards. In 2020, he published Canada: A Very Short Introduction as part of Oxford University Press’s Very Short Introduction series. He is currently writing a biography of Ramsay Cook.
History has always been my first love. I received an MA in Canadian history from McGill University, which is where I met Don. At the time, McGill had an onerous MA program, which required a year of classes followed by a year of original research and writing. We joked that we did two-thirds of the work for a PhD and received one-third of the credit. Nonetheless, the skills I learned in that program stood me in good stead as a filmmaker.
My first job in film was given to me by broadcast legend Christa Singer, a prodigious network executive who had been at the CBC since the dawn of the television era and, by the mid-1990s, had worked at TVOntario for over 20 years. Christa taught me just about everything I know about filmmaking. When we started filming a documentary on women and heart disease, I was still stuck in the academic tradition. I wanted statements rendered in full sentences, beautifully expressed by articulate people. But Christa wanted emotion. In our documentary, heart disease was secondary; the women were first. She found two women who had undergone invasive and life-threatening open-heart surgery. One cried as she related her experience; her grief and fear made audiences care about all women in this predicament. It was the most important lesson I ever learnt: emotions matter.
Christa Singer and I while filming Wisdom of the Heart. I convinced Christa to interview me for a job and borrowed a Bay Street lawyer’s suit. She hired me on the condition that I swore never to wear it again.
What I discovered from this was that writing history and making documentaries were not at all alike. The study of history emphasizes reason over passion. Film thrives on passion; in fact, it doesn’t work without it. And in academia, for the most part, you work alone. Filmmaking, on the other hand, is collaborative. Everybody, from the producers to the cinematographer to the editor to the broadcaster, shapes what you see on screen. The director is but one voice. Sometimes an important one, sometimes not.
This is not to say that my academic training was irrelevant. Most of my friends in the business who went to film school instead of university wish they had received a broader education in the arts before they specialized. The same organizational thinking that I had learnt in grad school has served me well time and again. Choosing interview subjects, coming up with a shooting schedule, preparing a typical day in the field, getting the lighting just right: it all requires tight coordination, strict discipline, and patience.
Subscribe to my Blog
In filmmaking, reason resides behind the camera. Emotion is reserved for the screen, something York University Professor Megan Davies understood intuitively.
In 1977, the National Film Board producedMental Patients’ Association (MPA), a short documentary that followed the iconic story of the first group of patients to be deinstitutionalized and take their care into their own hands. These Vancouverites formed a communal living and support group, fundamentally reordering Canada’s mental health landscape and, in the process, becoming a model worldwide.
When Megan connected with the founders in the 2010s to undertake an oral history project, they suggested that she make a follow-up documentary film instead. “Writing a historical text allows a lot of information to be conveyed, sources to be documented, arguments weighed, and contexts built. It is very measured. Whereas I discovered that making a film brought the emotion of the lived experience forward in a way that text could not. It was more immediate. And it gave a power to the work of history that I had not experienced before,” she said.
Professor Megan J. Davies has worked extensively in activist history projects that connect with the community, including Madness Canada/folie Canada. In producing the documentary The Inmates Are Running the Asylum, she radically altered her traditional approach to history scholarship.
For his part, historian Antony Anderson made the reverse journey, from filmmaker to historian. In 1993, having received seed money for a documentary on the life of Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson, he recorded many interviews but was unable to find the funding to complete the project. By 2015, most of the people he interviewed had passed away, and the interviews had now become historically valuable. “I had all these great interviews with his political and diplomatic colleagues, including with the last surviving members of the British delegates to the United Nations, people who witnessed Pearson in action. Nobody had talked to these people,” Antony recalled. “I didn’t want these interviews rotting away in film cans and so they functioned as a primary source for the book.”
The Diplomat: Lester Pearson and the Suez Crisis (2015) was nominated for the John W. Dafoe Book Prize. “Initially, switching genres felt second best, but then I quickly realized that writing a book allowed me to go way deeper into the story than the film would have. The intellectual rewards were profound.”
Antony Anderson spoke with Steve Paikin on The Agenda about his book The Diplomat: Lester Pearson and the Suez Crisis. A senior fellow at the Bill Graham Centre for Contemporary International History, Antony writes documentaries for various national and international broadcasters.
But if The Diplomat is in every library in the country, not every film is. In fact, some are all but impossible to access. Peter Raymont is one of Canada’s most awarded and prolific filmmakers, with a career that spans almost 50 years. His breakout movie, at least for me, was The World is Watching. Made in 1988, it captured the reality of the Sandinista revolution from the campesinos’ (peasant farmers’) perspective rather than what the journalists usually covered for the evening news. “We felt we were documenting history,” Peter told me.
Finding these films is becoming increasingly difficult. Although many were sponsored by the Canadian taxpayer – through broadcasters, the National Film Board, and tax credit or investment programs – it is often next to impossible to screen them either because they were shot on technologies that no longer exist, and haven’t been digitized, or because rights issues prevent them from being widely screened.
“I think it would be really useful if my films and other documentaries were freely available for teachers and students,” says Peter. “Canada has a rich tradition of documentary, and these films should be made as easily and readily available as books.”
Access to materials is one issue, but in addition, we now face the very real problem of having to discern real historical material or archival footage from fake. “In an already fast-changing industry, documentaries are certainly going through a roller coaster ride of their own,” says Deadline’s Executive Editor Dominic Patten. “Technology, specifically AI, is rendering what is the truth visually to simply be whatever software or whatever keystroke you make.”
This concern keeps people like Elizabeth Klinck awake at night. “Deepfakes are everywhere. Synthetic material that is indistinguishable from primary sources risks being passed along online, in educational materials, in other films. It can potentially forever “muddy the historical record.”
Elizabeth is one of the founders of the Visual Researcher’s Society of Canada, an organization of professional visual researchers and archive producers whose services are used regularly by filmmakers and many others who need an experienced person to source footage and still imagery and obtain permissions for their use.
Elizabeth Klinck has worked as a producer, editorial and visual researcher, and clearance specialist on numerous award-winning international documentary films and interactive projects, which have garnered Emmy, CSA, Peabody, and Oscar awards.
So, how do we protect our historical legacy on film? “One solution to protect the veracity of the documentary historical record is a bill being put forward by the Spanish government, which would level large fines on companies that use content generated by AI without proper labeling,” Elizabeth told me. “All fake or AI images would have to contain a watermark that would identify them as such.”
According to Elizabeth, protecting this legacy is vital for cultural survival. “Documentary films capture life’s stories, traditions, and historical events for future generations. They document the diversity of human experience, ensuring that stories are not forgotten over time. I believe they are the ultimate historical artefact.”
Films as the ultimate historical artifact. Now that is a celebration that I can get behind.
A few years ago, at the McMichael gallery exhibition called Uninvited: Canadian Women Artists in the Modern Moment I came across a beautiful portrait of a young woman painted in 1935 by Marion Dale Scott. I recognized the subject at once. It was Miss Gordon, as I called her, who had lived just down the street from us in Toronto. I had grown up looking at an almost identical picture of her that hung above her fireplace.
Marian Dale Scott, Portrait of Lois Gordon in a Russian Dress, 1935. As seen at the McMichael Canadian Art Collection.
I can’t remember the first time I met Lois Gordon but apparently, it was love at first sight. She was 64 years old at the time. And I was five. I’m told that every evening, I would wait faithfully in her garden for her to return from work. My father was left in the somewhat embarrassing position of ritually having to walk down the street to retrieve me. And, so, a deal was cut. Once a week, she would invite me in, serve me ginger ale, and we would play cards for half an hour. This soon evolved into one hour, then twice a week, and would go on for eight years.
Lois Gordon, painted by Marion Dale Scott. Date unknown. Private collection.
Miss Gordon shared a house in north Toronto with her good friend Miss Latimer. Their living room was filled with antique pine furniture and high wing-backed chairs that would be ever so slightly rearranged when I pulled out the well-worn card table from its storage place, unfolded its spindly metal legs, planted it firmly in place, and started clumsily shuffling the cards.
Subscribe to my Blog
She would serve up our drinks in dark green glasses. The ice would clink as she sipped on her scotch. Puffing on her Colt cigarillos, her bright red nails flashing above her bejeweled fingers, she would fling her cards down in triumph when she beat me at a game. I would shyly reach for the pretzels, ask for more ginger ale, and plot my comeback, while Miss Latimer, ensconced in her armchair after a long day teaching at the university, would steadfastly refuse to be drawn into the game.
Lois Gordon in retirement.
As I grew up, we played cards less often and finally stopped all together. In 1989, the two women retired to Kingston, and, following Miss Latimer’s passing, Miss Gordon returned to Winnipeg to be with her family.
In 1999, I was in Winnipeg for a small screening of my film Just Watch Me. It was a warm, sunny September afternoon, and dead center in the middle of the auditorium sat Miss Gordon, no longer the towering figure of my childhood, but a grey-haired diminutive woman of 93.
Catherine Annau and Lois Gordon, Toronto 2001. Lois was a striking and formidable woman. Her long dark-red hair crowned her head in a bun well into her 70s. In winter, she wore a thick black cape, which she flung over her shoulder in defiance of the cold.
Still spirited, she invited me back to her apartment, not for a card game, but for some scotch and conversation. On the wall was the portrait that had hung over the fireplace in Toronto, the one that had tantalizingly hinted at an exciting life lived long before I met her. It was then that she told me about that life.
She was the daughter of the Presbyterian minister, Charles William Gordon, a preacher by day and novelist by night. Part of the now largely forgotten generation of highly successful best-selling Canadian novelists, he had written forty-three books under the nom-de-plume Ralph Connor, selling over 5 million copies. Six of his novels were made into silent films, and one, The Sky Pilot, by the renowned director King Vidor. The income generated from the sales of these novels made Charles Gordon a millionaire, allowing Miss Gordon, along with her five sisters and one brother, to grow up in a life of relative luxury.
Ralph Connor House, Miss Gordon’s childhood home, is now a National Historic Site. Miss Gordon’s father had it built in 1913 and lived in it until he died in 1937. It then became the home of the University Women’s Club of Winnipeg.
But rather than rely on her father’s money, Lois struck out on her own, moving to Montreal, earning her keep working at a prestigious girls’ school and taking part in the thriving artistic and political community the city offered up. It must have been here that she entered a friendship with Marion Dale Scott and had her portrait painted.
During the Second World War, she served as an officer in the Canadian Women’s Army Corps in Newfoundland. She then came to Toronto to take up social work, a profession she remained in for the rest of her life. It was at the University of Toronto’s School of Social Work that she met Miss Latimer. As Miss Gordon explained it, since she was always cooking for her, and they were always eating together, they decided that they might as well move in together. And so, they did.
I was lucky enough to see her one last time, in June 2001. She had come east for a celebration of her 95th birthday. Surrounded by friends, she talked passionately about the latest plays she had just taken in at Stratford.
Inside Miss Gordon’s childhood home in Winnipeg. On the mantle is a family photo with Miss Gordon as a child.
Gracious, lively, and feisty to the end, Lois Gordon touched everyone she met. She probably taught me more than anyone about how to live life to the fullest, seize victory from the jaws of defeat, and most importantly, how to do it with humour, candor, and style.
At a time when many women didn’t have a great deal of autonomy, she lived life on her own terms as an independent woman. Lois created and wrote her own story and encouraged the women who met her to do the same.
LOIS GORDON: Born 2 May 1906; died 18 June 2003.
The newly constructed Musée LouisHémon sits within Éspace Péribonka on the shore of Lac Saint-Jean. Photo courtesy of Musée Louis Hémon by Carole-Tremblay.
What can a novel, first published in French over 100 years ago, teach us about Canada today? A lot, in fact. Watching Canadians rise to the threats of a White House bully, I am reminded of Maria Chapdelaine, a slim novel about a young woman’s choice: to marry one man, and stay in Canada, or marry another man, and move to the United States. In effect, Maria’s choice – Canada or the United States – is one we have in front of us now.
Maria Chapdelaine: A Tale of French Canada is a best-selling French novel that you likely have never heard of. Written by Louis Hémon in 1913, it tells the tale of a young woman who lives with her family on a farm near the village of Péribonka, Quebec.
Sophie Grégoire Trudeau in CBC’s Ottawa studio reading extracts from Maria Chapdelaine for the Ideas documentary. Photo courtesy of CBC Radio.
Like many contemporary Canadians, the fictional Maria finds herself sorely tempted by the promise of American wealth and weather. She dreams of “the far-off wonders” that America promises.
Translated into over 20 languages, Maria Chapdelaine l is considered one of the most widely read French novels in the world. Photo courtesy of Musée Louis-Hémon.
Yet Maria ultimately chooses to remain. In the novel’s most powerful passage, she hears the voice of Quebec. “Thus spake the voice: Three hundred years ago, we came. And we have remained…in this land of Quebec, no one shall die and no one shall suffer change.” Maria Chapdelaine is a novel of survivance: survival. Cultural survival. And it is as true now as it was then.
Author Louis Hémon (seated under the X) with Samuel Bedard to his left. This photo was probably taken on October 4, 1912, at the wedding celebrations of A. Henri-Tanner. Photo courtesy of Musée Louis-Hémon.
For my recent CBC Radio Ideas documentary, “The Many Lives of Maria Chapdelaine” I interviewed filmmaker Sébastien Pilote who so strongly identified with the novel that in 2021 he released his own dramatic film version. Pilote’s great-great-grandfather left Quebec to work in America’s North Eastern factories. It was not a happy experience. Not only was he afraid of losing his language and his culture, but he found the American dream was nothing more than a hollow chimera and returned to Quebec.
Actress Sara Monpetit as Maria with Director Sébastien Pilote on the set of Maria Chapdelaine. Photo courtesy of Sébastien Pilote.
The novel makes clear an existential threat that many French Canadians have lived with for more than a century. And now, in the face of Trump’s tariffs and his talk of Canada becoming the 51st state, many English Canadians too find themselves wondering if the Canada they know will survive. Perhaps Pilote’s great-great-grandfather had been right to firmly shut the door on the United States and return to Quebec.
As an English-speaking Canadian whose parents both chose Canada, I grew up with a very different notion of survival: one embodied in Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau’s optimistic vision of a bilingual, multicultural Canada.
By the early 1970s, the push for bilingualism was everywhere, and by the late 1980s, I benefited from the federal government’s Summer Language Bursary Program, which sent university students to communities across the country to learn either English or French.
My placement took me to Chicoutimi, Quebec, Maria Chapdelaine country. We visited the tiny homestead where author Louis Hémon stayed and gathered material for what would become an international bestseller.
The Samuel Bédard house and adjoining barn in the former location with the tourist bicycle route in the foreground. At the height of Maria Chapdelaine-mania, tourists came from as far away as Japan. Photo courtesy of Musée Louis-Hémon.
One weekend my boyfriend and I decided to meet up in Quebec City. To continue progressing with my French, I insisted we speak French together all weekend. While having dinner in one of Quebec City’s cozy restaurants, I was struggling to keep up my side of the conversation in broken French when a diner approached our table. “Excusez-moi,” this middle-aged Quebec man said to us, “but I couldn’t help overhearing your conversation. It makes me proud to hear you trying to learn my language.” His words left an indelible impression on me.
The newly constructed Musée Louis-Hémon sits within Éspace Péribonka on the shores of Lac Saint-Jean. The Samuel Bédard house and barn are now located inside the interior courtyard. Photo courtesy of Musée Louis-Hémon. Photo by Carole Tremblay.
Many people have told me they won’t be traveling to the United States anytime soon. It takes a lot to anger a Canadian. And it takes even more for English Canadians, who have perhaps never before worried about losing their birthright, to come face to face with a threat to their survival. Though Maria Chapdelaine is a novel about French Canada written more than a century ago, it can speak to all Canadians now. Maria’s choice is our choice.
Clarence Alphonse Gagnon (1881–1942), Eutrope Gagnon Visits, 1928/1933, pastel and coloured pencil with gouache on paper sheet: 22.2 x 22.1 cm; image: 18.7 x 18.6 cm, Gift of Colonel R.S. McLaughlin, McMichael Canadian Art Collection, 1969.4.10
Long before she rediscovered one of the most talented lithographers of the 19th century and curated an international blockbuster featuring his work, Katharine Lochnan had dreamt of taking a trip to Ireland to explore her roots. When she finally found room in her busy schedule as Deputy Director of Research and The R. Fraser Elliott Curator of Prints and Drawings at the Art Gallery of Ontario, her timing was impeccable. Unbeknownst to her, the trip to County Clare to look into archival records coincided with a rare event in her ancestral line: the second ever reunion of the ‘Ui Lochlainn’ clan and the first in a decade. “To arrive there at that moment was extraordinary synchronicity,” she told me when we sat down in her office at the Art Gallery of Ontario.
Warmly welcomed by the group, Lochnan found the trip to be both personally and professionally propitious. Clambering over the rocky countryside, she fell in love with the landscape. “I just had the feeling of something greater than ourselves,” she said. “I felt that it held the mysteries of my own existence back to the dawn of time.”
When she returned to Toronto, Lochnan embarked on another journey. Though raised a Catholic, she had left the Church after Vatican II. Nonetheless, she registered for courses in the spiritual direction program Regis College, a Jesuit Institute associated with the University of Toronto. Following a year of intense study with a group of like-minded individuals, she informed her classmates that she was thinking of retiring from the Art Gallery of Ontario to devote herself to ministry. But their response was not what she expected. “They told me ‘there’s a problem: you’re already in your ministry. It’s curating’. I said curating isn’t a ministry. Oh yes, they said, it is,” Lochnan told me. “My teacher said we feel you are already in your ministry and you still have something else to do.”
So Lochnan stayed on at the AGO. And she didn’t have to wait too long to find her calling. Later that year, while attending a conference in New York City, she visited the Metropolitan Museum of Art. “I always go to look at paintings at the MET. This time I found myself wondering if there was such a thing as a mystical landscape. And all of a sudden I began to see the 19th century pictures as if for the first time. I thought ‘Oh my God! Monet is doing it! Van Gogh is doing it! Gauguin is doing it! And I knew I was onto something.”
At dinner later that night, Paul Lang, the new Deputy Director and Chief Curator of the National Gallery of Canada asked her if she had any ideas for exhibitions. “I told him I’m really interested in mysticism and landscape. To my surprise, he said ‘that’s a brilliant idea. I’ll support you’.” Lochnan recalls that from that moment on “doors just kept opening”. When she approached her colleagues at the AGO, though normally hesitant about religious subjects, they supported her idea. “I made it clear that this was about the spiritual, that mysticism was at the root of all religions.”
Lochnan then flew to Paris to meet with the Director of the Musée d’Orsay. She was on a mission to convince him to lend her key pictures from the collection. “Not only did he say that I could I borrow them,” Lochnan said. “But he told me he wanted the show.”
Thrilled, Lochnan invited colleagues, award-winning author and curator Roald Nasgaard and one of the leading world experts in Van Gogh, art historian Bogomila Welsh-Ovcharov, to work with her as guest curators. The group began to select which images would ultimately be included. There was one problem. “As art historians, we couldn’t articulate the mystical,” said Lochnan. “Frankly, I felt that we were on holy ground and needed some help.” So Lochnan assembled a group of theologians and the team began to form a common language. “Together we focused on and identified the characteristics of what we called mystical landscapes. Historians and scientists joined us and we had the most extraordinary conversations.”
Charles Marie Dulac, a little-known late nineteenth century French lithographer, became central to the concept of the show. Considered by some to be a mystic, Dulac explored themes and aesthetic principles that guided the committee’s search. “Once we had spent time with his work and we understood the qualities that were inherent in it, we found it easier to identify the mystical qualities in other people’s work. So he became a kind of a litmus test.”
Lochnan had first discovered Dulac in the 1980s. “I was at Fred Mulder’s gallery in Hampstead. Fred was an art dealer from Saskatchewan who specialized in 19th century French prints. When I saw this portfolio of lithographs called Paysages, I thought that it was simply gorgeous. And I asked Fred ‘Who is this guy? His work is beautiful’.”
Though he received recognition in his own time, by the late 20th century, Dulac had largely been forgotten. Born in Paris in 1866, Dulac worked as a commercial artist, supporting himself by painting stage sets and apartment interiors, and working in the wallpaper industry. In his early twenties, he was diagnosed with lead poisoning, having absorbed lead through the white paint he worked with. Knowing that he had only a short time left to live, Dulac entered a Franciscan convent in Vézelay, Burgundy. There, he had a conversion experience. He dedicated the rest of his life to making works of art that were devotional in nature. Unable to become a monk because of his poor health, when Dulac died in 1898 at age 32, he became a tertiary, a member of the lay Third Order, and was buried wearing a Franciscan monk’s robe.
Dulac worked extensively in lithography. As a medium, it was beginning to be adopted by fine artists like James McNeill Whistler and Édouard Vuillard. Dulac demonstrated a sophisticated mastery of the form that surpassed his peers. “Perhaps because of his applied art background, he was able to combine stones with zinc plates, use many colors and incredibly subtle colors, and superimpose things and register them,” said Lochnan. “His palette is very understated, very subtle, and very idiosyncratic. He knew how to work in a way that gives an illusion of three dimensions but is also two-dimensional. He would often play with the same image, changing only the colors that he used.
Lochnan fell in love with his work. “I began to buy Dulac hand over fist,” she said. Work quickly spread in the art world that she was collecting him. Lochnan recalls that every summer a dealer from New York would arrive in Toronto with prints to sell. “He began to look for stuff for me. He brought me drawings and pastels and then the ten variations of the same plate, which were ultimately in the exhibition. And,” she added with some satisfaction, “they sold me those at a discount.”
She soon discovered she had an ally in former diplomat and ambassador to the United States, Allan Gotlieb. A great lover of 19th century French prints, Gotlieb had amassed an extensive private collection, which included work by Dulac. “When he saw that I was buying Dulac, he offered us some beautiful prints from his private collection,” Lochnan told me. “It is thanks to Alan that we have the variations on some of the plates in our portfolios.”
Lochnan was determined that the AGO become the North American institute of record for Dulac, an objective she ultimately achieved. From the research done to date, it appears that Dulac created two major series of prints (otherwise known as portfolios). Suite de Paysages has eight original lithographs and zincographs and Le Cantique des Creatures has nine impressions. He died before he was able to compete his final series, Credo. It contains only three prints. Lochnan was able to assemble two of these portfolios, the Suite de Paysages and Le Cantique des Creatures, in addition to many variations on individual prints. It is that collection that lies at the heart of Mystical Landscapes. At the AGO installation, Dulac was the sole artist to have his own exhibition room. Entering through a doorway from the main hall into an intimate rectangular salon, I had the sensation of being in a place of worship or chapel. This effect was quite deliberate. “We wanted to create a chapel like setting and a kind of sacred space. A sanctuary,” Lochnan confirmed.
Dulac’s plate The Canticle of Creatures is perhaps his most famous and impressive. Lochnan hung the ten variations of the print along one wall so that viewers could understand how he conveyed meaning through repetition and variation of colour and saturation. “The Canticle of St Francis’ is a hymn to nature as the great work of art of the creator,” Lochnan explained. “Dulac depicts a man plowing a field, creating the furrows in which to do the planting. And there is a little chapel there, dedicated to St. Barbara, who is the patron saint of storms. We see that the chapel is protected by this huge and wonderful tree.”
A historian on her team discovered that the Lord’s Prayer was penciled in the margin of one of the proof impressions of La Chapelle a Minerville. “Knowing this, we realized that Dulac is inspired by the first line from the Lord’s Prayer, ‘Give us this day our daily bread’.” But because his work is so evocative, Lochnan believes that the viewer can feel his intention that without having to know the Catholic liturgy. “The beauty of his prints is that they hint at something rather than trying and explain it fully,” explains Lochnan. “If you’re trying to deal in the realm of the transcendent you don’t want to be too explicit.”
Dulac didn’t paint many pictures and the five paintings that are found in the exhibition are among the few that survive. Four of them depict a sun setting over the Tiber Valley and were painted when Dulac visited Assisi, the home of St. Francis. These paintings are emblematic of a mystical union, according to Lochnan. “The sun has three rays coming out of it, which are Trinitarian. The notion of the Trinity (God, the Son, and the Holy Spirit) is very important in Franciscan theology. All the colors are running together, creating a sense of unity where the landscape quietly disappears as the sun sets. I think that these sunsets, where the last rays of light are disappearing, is Dulac’s way of coming towards mystical unity and harmony.”
Unexpectedly for Lochnan, the Dulac room became a personal place of sanctuary and comfort. As she was in the midst of the final preparation for the opening in Toronto, Lochnan’s husband of forty years, the architect George Yost, suddenly died. Overcome with grief, she debated taking time off but ultimately continued to work. “My colleagues didn’t know it at the time but sometimes I would slip into the Dulac room and cry. Then I would pull myself together and go out and carry on.”
Five years in the making, Mystical Landscapes was a critical and popular success, boasting capacity crowds. After five months, it closed in February 2017 and was reinstalled at the Musée d’Orsay, where it opened last month. Lochnan travelled to Paris to supervise the installation and attend the opening. “The opening at Orsay was overwhelming,” Lochnan told me. “There were literally thousands of people either in the galleries or waiting outside to enter the museum.” The exhibition is so popular that the numbers of viewers in Paris is exceeding previous records at Orsay. Projected attendance by the time the exhibition closes is close to half a million visitors. “It is so popular that they have to restrict entrants to 4,500 per day for the safety of the art works.”
Crowds queuing outside the Musée d’Orsay in Paris to see Mystical Landscapes. By the time the show closes, close to three quarters of a million people will have seen it.
And after forty-seven years at the AGO, Lochnan recently stepped down as Senior Curator of International Exhibitions, and now holds the title of Senior Curator Emeritus. Not one to retire, she envisions curating a solo show that would give Dulac his due. “I think he is a fascinating artist and he’s become very important to me. I don’t know if the Gallery would ever want to do a Dulac exhibition but we have the material,” she says with pride. “You know, nobody’s really looked at this before. And it is ripe for further development. Maybe that is what I’ll be doing from now on with my team: continuing to develop what we’ve begun.”
Au-delà des étoiles, le paysage mystique, de Monet à Kandinsky (Mystical Landscapes) is running at the Musée d’Orsay until June 25, 2017.
Johnnie Eisen’s recent exhibition Breath at Toronto’s Akasha Art Projects is a visually arresting show comprised of nine large-scale colour photographs, each one a tightly composed image of a single tree. Under Eisen’s gaze, the intricate yet simple beauty of tree trunks and the elaborate patterns of their bark is intimately framed. The photographs, with their interplay of light, texture and detail, invite viewers to reevaluate their relationship to the physical world.
For Eisen this is the point. “We are simply not alive to what’s around us,” he told me when we sat down at his home a few weeks ago. “We keep on moving. We get in our cars and slam the doors shut, shutting ourselves off. We walk down the street, not looking at anyone.” According to Eisen, trees offer us a point of connection.
Photographs from the series Breath by Johnnie Eisen. Exhibition at Akasha Art Projects, Toronto.
Now 71, Eisen’s fascination with nature goes all the way back to his childhood in midtown Toronto. He remembers taking elementary school trips to Sherwood Park. It was there, at age ten that he first started taking photos of woodlands. “Trees always conveyed a comforting presence to me. That may have come about within the first year or so of my life. When I was placed in my crib for my afternoon nap, I would fall asleep while watching the shadows of leaves dancing about on the window shades.”
Tree 2 by Johnnie Eisen, 36″ x 45″. From the exhibition Breath, 2017.
Having known Eisen for over twenty years, I’ve had the pleasure of watching his career evolve from being a much sought after editorial photographer whose work was featured in magazines such as Saturday Night and Report on Business, to having his photographic prints acquired by the National Gallery of Canada and private companies such as the TD Bank. The renowned design firm Yabu Pushelberg chose one of Eisen’s photos from his series Entanglement for their interiors of the W Hotel, Taipei. Eisen’s work is also found in the private collections of award-winning Canadian filmmaker Atom Egoyan and Game of Thrones cinematographer Jonathan Freeman. With four decades of exhibitions to his credit, he has come a long way since his sold his first image to the National Film Board’s Still’s Division.
#4 from the series Engtaglement, 2010. A 7′ x 7′ version of this was commissioned by Yabu Pushelberg for the W Hotel in Tapai.
In 2012 a pairing of silver-based photographic prints were exhibited in Flora and Fauna: 400 Years of Artists Inspired by Nature, at the National Gallery of Canada. Among many other artists, this exhibition included works by Rembrandt and Lucien Freud and toured galleries across the country. “It’s odd to be able to say that you’re showing with Freud and Rembrandt at the National Gallery, just upstairs from Van Gogh.”
#16 from the series A Deeper Silence by Johnnie Eisen. Included in the exhibition Flora and Fauna: 400 Years of Artists Inspired by Nature at the National Gallery of Canada, 2012.
#22 from the series A Deeper Silence by Johnnie Eisen. From the exhibition Flora and Fauna: 400 Years of Artists Inspired by Nature at the National Gallery of Canada, 2012.
The origin of his latest show Breath took place several years ago when Eisen was shooting images for his previous exhibition The Woods. For TheWoods, his composite, multilayered colour images suggested a nature that is almost impenetrable. Impossibly lush and dense, this is a dark, uncertain vision of nature that lies somewhere between the real world and that of a dream.
#9 by Johnnie Eisen. From the series The Woods, 2014.
While working on The Woods, he had a revelation. “I started to look at certain trees and listening to the landscape around the trees. I began to think about what the trees were ‘hearing’ and found myself listening to the environment they exist in. I had nothing formal in mind at the time because I was really absorbed in the other project.”
The listening triggered a second element, which Eisen would incorporate into Breath. He recorded the ambient sound around each tree in the series. Using their smart phones, viewers can choose to listen to these tracks while viewing each photo. The results are not what you might expect: what you see may belong to nature but what you hear is decidedly urban. Trucks and passing traffic can be heard in the distance. For Eisen, this dissonance is as much spiritual as it is real. “We’re all so deeply distracted by the ever increasing noise that permeates our lives, and I wanted to seduce people with images that are beautiful and voluptuous. The audio component provides a startling contrast. This is my way of stating a simple idea, simply and directly, “C’mon people, slow down, look around and take a breath.”
#8 by Johnnie Eisen. From the series The Woods, 2014.
Although primarily working with photography, this is not the first time that Eisen has utilized other media in his artwork. His 2003 work Sittings, a 10-hour collection of 60 video “portraits” toured across the country. What unites Sittings with Breath is a line that goes through all of his work, a sense of ambiguity and inquisitiveness, a yearning to delve beneath the surface of the image to reveal the inner life and light. Challenging the truthfulness of the photograph, he produces precise, well-wrought ambiguity.
In 2009, Eisen was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease and his voice has weakened to the point where he can be hard to hear. The illness has impacted his mobility as well, but with the help of Bob Dirstein, his spouse of 37 years, he is still able to explore subjects that have always fascinated him. “My work is not about my illness, but unquestionably, it has influenced it,” he said. “Bringing the trees and the soundscape together was, for me, purely an emotional response. I wanted to pay attention to the soundscape around us. And I wanted the trees to be utterly gorgeous.”
Together for 37 years, Johnnie Eisen (left) and Bob Dirstein married in 2005.
As the world’s population increasingly lives in cities, we are becoming more and more divorced from the natural world, leading us to take trees for granted. Eisen’s accomplishment is all the more remarkable for making us encounter these magnificent plants anew.
Negotiations are currently under way for Breath to move to the First Canadian Place Gallery for May 10- June 30, 2017. For those who want more information on Eisen’s work, he can be reached via email at johnnie.eisen@sympatico.ca.
Frances Anne Hopkins, London, England 1838–London, England 1919, Canoe Manned by Voyageurs Passing a Waterfall, 1869, Oil on canvas, Library and Archives Canada Purchase, 1923.
Billed as the “first exhibit examining the history of women’s self-portraiture in Canada”, The Artist Herself at the Art Gallery of Hamilton was one best art shows I’ve seen in many years. It took a fresh and unique look at the work of Canadian women artists spanning the years from 1700 to the early 1960s. Composed of fifty-eight carefully curated paintings, drawings, textiles and other objects from over twenty-eight lenders, the exhibition included everything from traditional self-portraits to button blankets to dolls.
Curated by Alicia Boutilier of the Agnes Etherington Art Centre in Kingston and Tobi Bruce of the AGH, the show was conceived, in part, as an homage to their mentors, Dorothy Farr and Natalie Luckyj, who had created the first show ever to look at historical women’s art in Canada, the seminal From Women’s Eyes: Women Painters In Canada exhibit in 1975. Longtime collaborators and friends, Boutilier and Bruce wanted to do a new show to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the first.
Curators Tobi Bruce and Alicia Boutilier installing Canoe Manned by Voyageurs Passing a Waterfall by Frances Anne Hopkins in The Artist Herself: Self-Portraits by Canadian Historical Women Artists at Agnes Etherington Art Centre.
“We realized that we couldn’t do From Women’s Eyes again,” Boutilier told me when the three of us talked by phone last week. “I was thinking self-portraits would be an interesting theme. There had been exhibitions of women’s self-portraits internationally, and a number of books, but this had not been done in Canada.” When Boutilier first made the suggestion to Bruce in early 2012, Bruce was lukewarm. “Frankly I thought it sounded really boring,” Bruce laughed.
Mattie Gunterman, Mattie on Stove, with Rose and Ann Williams, Nettie L. Mine, BC 1903, Modern print from original glass negative, Vancouver Public Library, Gift of Henry Gunterman. Photo: Vancouver Public Library.
But then the two spent a weekend tossing around various ideas and drilling down on questions of identity: what exactly constitutes a self-portrait? Does it have to be concerned with likeness? Must self-portraiture depict the face of the maker? Merely posing these questions made them realize that they were onto something, and that they “wanted to approach women’s self-portraiture in a new way, not in the traditional canonical sense.”
Pauline Johnson’s Dress as seen in The Artist Herself: Self-Portraits by Canadian Historical Women Artists at Agnes Etherington Art Centre. Photo: Paul Litherland.
By rejecting the traditional equation that likeness equals identity, Boutilier and Bruce had the genesis of an exciting new show. “Once we had this framework, we could argue about whether this work is a self-portrait or not,” Bruce said. “And now we could include a range of objects, such as textiles, in addition to painting.”
Marion Wilson (attributed to), Fort Rupert/T’sakis BC around 1892–1893–Comox BC, 1949, Button Blanket, Undated, Wool, mother-of-pearl, and abalone shell, Museum of Vancouver, Purchase, 1964.
Boutilier and Bruce reached out to fellow curators across the country, asking for their assistance in exploring this broadened notion of identity in relation to self-portraiture and seeking their expertise in locating exciting works. Once the working list was in place, they reached out to 35 colleagues (curators, artists, art historians, artist descendants), asking them to contribute short written commentaries on individual works. Having successfully applied for grant money to mount the exhibit, the two women were able to travel to various museums across the country to look at pieces first hand and determine if they would work in the upcoming show. “Not until you are in the space, do you really get a sense of the scale and if a piece will work,” Bruce said.
Emily Carr, Victoria BC 1871–Victoria BC 1945, Untitled (Self-Portrait), 1924–1925, Oil on paperboard, Vancouver Art Gallery, Emily Carr Trust, 1942.
Eventually Boutilier and Bruce drew up a short list. Printing out reproductions, the two curators laid out their selections. They looked for diversity of expression and material. In addition to reaching across 200 years, they wanted to have regional variety and a balance of artists with ‘name recognition’ and women who were completely unknown. A practicum student working on the project under Boutilier’s supervision, for example, came across the work of Bertha May Ingle, a 19th-century southern Ontario painter and brought it to her attention. “It was just a small self-portrait, and yet, it was so powerful.”
Bertha May Ingle, Puslinch Township ON 1878–Toronto ON 1962, Self-Portrait, Around 1901, Oil on canvas, Private Collection.
As time went on, the two women began to explore how the objects ‘spoke’ to each other. “We moved the reproductions around and to see how they worked together,” Boutilier said. “And we began to have a sense of certain adjacencies.” These discoveries began to change the shape and selections for the show. “What about this one of Emily Carr with her back to the viewer? Or a painted tea canister by Maud Lewis? We started to explore what fits.”
Maud Lewis, South Ohio (Nova Scotia), 1903 – Digby (Nova Scotia), 1970, Painted Cookie Tin with Flowers 1960s, oil on metal, Art Gallery of Nova Scotia, Halifax. Purchased by the Province of Nova Scotia.
Amongst the objects that captured my heart were two tiny Muskego Cree dolls, created around 1790-1800 by women who lived close to a Hudson’s Bay post. According to Bruce, these dolls are extremely rare – there are only seven remaining in the world and none in Canada. “It was very tricky to get them at all,” recalled Bruce. After a false start, they were able to borrow them from a private collection in California. “One of the exciting things about the dolls is that they represent cross-cultural exchange,” Boutilier said. “They incorporate both traditional and trade materials: porcupine quills, but also cloth and glass beads.”
The Artist Herself at the Agnes Etherington Art Centre 2016 Summer Season Launch. Photo: Tim Forbes.
The Artist Herself ultimately toured four galleries: the Agnes at Queen’s University in Kingston, the Art Gallery of Hamilton, the Art Gallery of Greater Victoria and the Kelowna Art Gallery. As it turned out, no two shows were quite the same. Though Boutilier and Bruce travelled with the show to help hang it, each host curator was given the freedom to place the objects in their gallery as they wished. “The in-house curators know their spaces. We gave them the opportunity to shape the show at their venue. Bruce said. “Thus the show looked different in all four spaces. Visitors to each venue would have different exhibitions.”
Boutilier and Bruce faced an additional problem. Given the fragility of some of the work, not all of the 58 pieces were able to travel to all four venues. For example, Pauline Johnson’s buckskin dress, a showstopper at the Agnes in Kingston, was too fragile to travel. “That was a bit of heartbreak,” Bruce said. Photographs of the dress had to stand in for the rest of the tour. “Oil paintings are quite durable compared to textiles or works on paper,” Boutilier told me. On occasion, objects like the button blankets and some photographic prints, were swapped mid-tour for similar objects.
Hannah Maynard, Bude, England 1834–Victoria BC 1918, Untitled (Tea Time), Around 1893, Modern print from original glass negative, Royal BC Museum, BC Archives, Victoria.
The show’s comprehensive catalogue serves as a delightful reminder of the captivating work these two women brought together. The exhibition fundamentally shifted the way I think about Canada’s visual heritage. Though I love decorative arts and prize crafts, I had unconsciously seen paintings and craft as telling different stories, instead of having the potential to create a unified narrative. Brought all together, the creative output represented in The Artist Herself, showed just how many women wanted to leave their mark. I began to wonder if, when it came to women’s art in Canada, we had just been too blind to see what was plainly in front of us.
Was there any possibility of a remount for Canada’s 150th anniversary? Alas, the answer was a flat no. “Once The Artist Herself went up and was successful, other galleries did inquire about hosting,” Boutilier said. But by then it was too late. No additional galleries could be added. “Private collectors often don’t want to part with their pieces for more than a year,” Bruce added. “That’s why we felt it was important to have a catalogue. So there would be some sort of record.” A virtual website, which could promote the whole of the exhibit, was, unfortunately, too expensive to produce.
As for their future plans, both Boutilier and Bruce are looking forward to collaborating again. “There are so many strands that we can take forward from this show, ideas we can riff on,” said Boutilier. I agree. As much as I wish that all Canadians could have seen this stunning show, I am looking forward to what these two remarkable curators will come up with next.
The Raft number two, 2015, 200 cm x 250 cm, oil on canvas, Sabina Sakoh
In the last two years, Sabina Sakoh has exhibited alongside international art luminaries Gerhard Richter, Georg Baselitz, and Sigmar Polke. Sakoh’s debut outing at New York’s esteemed Armory Show resulted in the sale of her painting December 2014 to a California collector. Not too bad for a German painter who is a relative newcomer to this side of the Atlantic; only a scant six months before the Armory show, she had her North American debut at Miami’s legendary Art Basel.
“Democracy is always at risk. “It can be destroyed by intolerance and by totalitarian impulses. To safeguard it, requires that we be conscious of its value.”
Better known in Europe and in Asia, she has been featured not once but twice in the prestigious fine art magazine Art Investor, and her work has appeared in major solo and group shows in Berlin, Cologne, Hamburg, Seoul, and Bejing. Guido Westerwelle, the highly respected former German Foreign Minister, was a major fan and placed her painting titled February 2012, over his desk. Her focus on democracy resonated with Westerwelle, and he had planned to place her works in German foreign offices worldwide when he suddenly passed away earlier this year.
Former German Foreign Minister Westerwelle told Sakoh that he often felt like the juggling clown in the painting. Photo Credit: Süddeusche Zeitung
Discovering new artists is always thrilling and on a recent trip to Germany, I couldn’t help but be seduced by Sakoh’s large scale, dramatic canvases, which I saw at her studio. Her style is rife with intriguing dualities: it is romantic yet naturalistic, contemporary but anchored by classical elements. Sakoh possesses formidable technical skills and marries high realism with dreamlike, almost abstract landscapes that her subjects occupy.
The Raft number nine, 2016, 200 cm x 180 cm, oil on canvas, Sabina Sakoh
After meeting her socially, I was invited to come to her studio for a sneak peak of her new show, Democracy on Air, which goes up this September in Munich. Her studio is located in Kistlerhof Studios, a vast complex of buildings that provides space to some of Munich’s visual artists, animators and tech developers. The sheer scale of the complex makes it resemble a Hollywood lot, and is a reminder of the considerable support Germany gives its artists. After finally locating the correct building, I rode a freight elevator to the second floor and wandered past the studios of graphic designers and other artists. When I found Sabina in her studio, she was hard at work, putting the finishing touches on one of her 16 canvases for her upcoming exhibit, which opens September 9.
The Raft number eight, 2016, 200 cm x 200 cm, oil on canvas, Sabina Sakoh
“I’ve been obsessed with the concepts of freedom and democracy for several years now,” she told me. “And I keep returning to this theme as the subject matter for my work.” She attributes this focus in part to having grown up in the Western half of a divided Germany, her childhood and adolescence marked by the fact that one half of the society was free and the other yearned to be. Another huge factor was the close relationship she had with her grandfather, Günther Strupp, also an artist. He had not only a profound influence on her artistic development but also on her worldview. “My grandfather suffered persecution at the hands of the Nazis. First he was interned at the Kemna Concentration camp and then a few years later, he was rounded up by the Gestapo and held at Stadelheim Prison because he was suspected of being part of an attempt on Hitler’s life. He was about to be executed when the Allied forces liberated the prison and saved his life. His experiences instilled in me not only a deep belief in the value of liberty but also a tremendous fear in the danger of tyranny.”
A friend of Bertolt Brecht, Sabina’s grandfather artist Günther Strupp was a major influence on Sakoh’s political and artistic development.
Sakoh’s new works feature individuals floating or isolated in a surreal space but all are unified by visual references from the French Revolution, images taken from the paintings of Delacroix and Gericault. “Freedom was fought for over the course of centuries, culminating in the French Revolution,” Sakoh said as we sat down in her studio sofa, surrounded by drying canvases. “But freedom is not just a historic accomplishment, an idea that exists only in books. It is something that we must fight for every day.” She pauses as if trying to find the exact words she wants in English. “Freedom is mankind’s major achievement. As artists we have a particular responsibility. Art requires freedom and freedom needs art.”
The Raft number five, 2016, 200 cm x 250 cm, oil on canvas, Sabina Sakoh
Michael Schultz, Sakoh’s dealer, underscored the uniqueness of her perspective. “What first attracted me to Sabina’s work was the political background of her artworks,” he told me in an email. “In every single painting she transforms current political tragedies into the time of revolution in the 18th century. These leaps in time are for me both exciting and stimulating. For me, Sabina Sakoh is one of the most authentic artists I have ever met.”
Although she mixes classical imagery with more contemporary visual allusions, she sometimes, as in the case of The Raft Number 8, places herself in the frame. Other times she uses her friends or their children as models. This mix of past and present is critical for her. “Today many of us forget what freedom actually means. We allow our feelings to be dulled by a need to conform, or by the relentless demands from a consumer society which focuses our attention on the need to acquire, making it a ‘virtue’ above all others.”
Sakoh in her studio. After graduating from the Academy of Fine Arts in Munich and the German Master School for Fashion and Design, Sakoh began as an illustrator before devoting herself to painting.
There can be no doubt about the urgency of Sakoh’s commitment to her themes. As I was leaving, by way of goodbye she gazed at me intensely and warned. “We must engage in a dialogue with history. We cannot allow our hard-won humanitarian values to be eradicated or our freedom will be destroyed”.
Democracy on Air opens September 9 at Galerie Filser Gräf, Munich and can be seen until October 14. Michael Schultz is also bringing her new work to this year’s Armory Show in NYC, and also to Art Basel Miami and other international art fairs. Additionally, he has plans for an exhibit in Los Angeles in 2018.
In September 1998, while directing my first feature-length documentary, Just Watch Me,a film about the impact of former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau‘s vision of a bilingual nation as seen through the lives of eight Gen Xers, I had the opportunity to travel to the Eastern Arctic city of Iqaluit, the capital of Nunavut. The trip from Toronto was and remains more expensive than a trip to Tokyo. That is a shame because it means that it’s easier for Canadians to travel to Japan than to go to our own far North, which as I discovered, is a place like no other.
The vastness and scale of the tundra is impossible to imagine. In the middle left of this photo, you can just make out a member of the crew. Photo credit: André Boisvert
The distance from Toronto to Iqaluit is 2,337 km (1452 miles). First I flew to Ottawa where I had to change planes before continuing almost due north. The second plane had a bulkhead halfway down: the front half held passengers and the back half cargo. Almost everything had to be flown in: lumber, groceries, medicine and office supplies. The flight from Ottawa to Iqaluit took three hours. Looking out the window midway, I watched as we passed north of the tree line, a feature, which had until then only existed as a mythical demarcation point in my geography texts.
Most of the houses are grouped together, so I was surprised to find this lone dwelling on a rocky outcropping overlooking the bay.
An amazing diversity of delicate yet hardy flora and fauna cover the rocks in the harbour.
I landed on the evening of Friday September 11, 1998. I remember the date very well because it was the same day that the Starr Report, the wide ranging investigation into then President Bill Clinton by independent counsel Kenneth Starr, was released. Looking out the window of my small hotel room and watching the news, I was struck by how remote such events seemed. Though Iqaluit shares the same time zone as Washington, it is worlds apart. Another interesting feature of the city that I was to discover, is that because of its location near the pole, Iqaluit has crystal clear radio reception from around world. Detroit radio was very popular.
After a successful hunt, skins are placed on stretchers to dry outside the hunter’s home. This was a common site.
Kids rode bicycles and drove ATVs around town. One popular destination for adults was the Road to Nowhere, which as the name suggests, ended abruptly at the outskirts of town.
I met this artist as he was working on his soap stone carvings which he sent to galleries in the south.
Formerly known as Frobisher Bay, Iqaluit is the only city in Nunavut. In 1998, it had a population of around 4,185. Today Iqaluit has grown to 6,699. The population of Nunavut itself is only 31,906, which seems very small considering the vastness of its territory: at 750,000 km2 (680,000 sq. mi.), Nunavut is equivalent in size to Western Europe. Formerly part of the Northwest Territories, following years of discussion and consultation, the decision had been made to divide that territory in two. As the eastern Arctic territory of Nunavut was set to officially launch in the spring of 1999, my trip coincided with a large building boom and great excitement as new government offices and agencies were being established.
This post office had just been constructed when I arrived and displays the graphically elegant syllabics that are used in written Inuktitut.
When I visited, Iqaluit was largely dry. This bar was one of two places in town that served alcohol and was packed with locals and anyone up on business or visiting friends on Friday and Saturday nights.
In early December 1998, I returned to Iqaluit with the crew to film an interview with crown attorney Doug Garson, whose efforts to become bilingual had led him from Manitoba to Quebec and ultimately to Iqaluit where he fell in love with and married an Inuit woman. This time, the dramatic golden light and mild temperatures of September had given way to a bitter cold, the kind most of us only read about in books.
A very cold me.
Iqaluit, literally means ‘place of many fish’. It sits on the edge of Frobisher Bay and has been used by the Inuit to fish for thousands of years. Photo credit: André Boisvert
We had rented a truck only to discover that the heater was broken. After we got over our initial shock, we realized that this was a blessing in disguise: the camera would not have tolerated the constant shifting between the extreme cold we were shooting in and the warmth of a heated truck and we would have lost a lot of valuable time waiting for it to adjust. Even when we filmed inside an unheated hockey arena, it took over an hour for the camera to warm up enough to film. Another major problem was the camera batteries, which drained rapidly in the cold.
The famous truck.
One of the key visual components of the film were sunrises which we filmed in various locations across Canada. All were stunning but I can honestly say that the dawn I experienced in Iqaluit was one of the most magnificent I have ever seen. In the far north, it takes the winter sun a long time to rise over the horizon. The sun rose slowly and never truly crested. Until it set at around 3 p.m., the daylight resembled what we call ‘magic hour’ – soft coral, pink hues lit the town all day long. It was astonishing and extraordinarily beautiful.
Setting up for the dawn shoot. Photo credit: André Boisvert
When filming was completed and before the plane departed, we wanted to go dogsledding and see how an igloo was built. We were all pretty disappointed that we had arrived too early in the season and there wasn’t enough snow yet. It is hard to know when I will have the opportunity to return but I will definitely time it so that I can do both of those things and more. Visiting the Nunavut Tourism site, I see that there are many wonderful and unique adventures still to be had in Canada’s far north. Now if only, they could do something about the price of those airfares!
Crew shot taken in the light of the setting afternoon sun outside the local church which is shaped like an igloo.
Marc Mayer has big plans for Canada’s sesquicentennial; he has committed to a complete redesign, reinstallation, and reinterpretation of the permanent Canadian and Indigenous collections at the National Gallery. As of May 2017, the now two separate collections shall be one.
“We have two art histories in Canada: Indigenous art, which goes back thousands of years, and Canadian art that begins only a few hundred years ago,” Marc explained to me as I caught up with him over lunch on a recent trip to Ottawa. “They are distinct but parallel stories of resilience, survival, interaction and transformation. And they have converged today in significant ways.”
By merging the galleries, Mayer believes that it will be easier to follow the two stories. “We will be able to more effectively show how they both evolve in relation to one another in a way that may help us understand our history, warts and all. And from a different perspective, it will also help situate the present moment. We can’t presume to tell the story of art in Canada by pretending that its oldest continuous cultures are not integral to the story and are incapable of making exceptional objects. That makes no sense!”
National Gallery of Canada Director Marc Mayer. Photo Credit: National Gallery of Canada
Mayer has been thinking about the problematic definitions of Canadian and Indigenous art for some time. “It has not been helpful to separate Indigenous Canadian art from the art of the settler communities. My predecessor understood that and a temporary approach was taken with a project called Art of this Land,” he said, taking a moment to reflect. “But by 2017, it’s time to commit to inclusion in a permanent and systematic way.”
Mayer has come to a more complex understanding of our history. “When you really look, you see that Indigenous people and the Europeans who settled here constantly interacted from the moment of contact, whether through trade, diplomacy or intermarriage. Canada’s aboriginal population was not hiding in the woods, oblivious to the strangers. They were in the towns trading, negotiating, and attempting to establish reasonable boundaries and the terms of collaboration. As much as our European ancestors resisted the idea, and too many still do, the aboriginal peoples of Canada and their cultures have always been, and will always be fundamental to the notion of Canadian identity.”
Norval Morrisseau, also known as Copper Thunderbird, Artist and Shaman Between Two Worlds, 1980
For Mayer, this question of how to best represent Indigenous art and Canadian art was the beginning of a voyage of discovery. “I began to question why do we tell these stories of art in separate galleries, for that matter in separate museums? There may be good, practical reasons to separate these different cultures from each other. But I believe there are equally good reasons not to. Especially in the case of an art museum where the emphasis is on the celebration of exceptional objects.”
Having headed up major galleries in New York, Paris, Toronto and Montreal before coming to Ottawa in 2009, Mayer knew that to successfully combine the National Gallery’s Indigenous art and Canadian art collections, collaboration would be critical. He opened up a dialogue with the curators of the two galleries and they set to work on developing an ambitious new plan.
This meant that everything was on the table, including the types of material that get displayed. “We concluded that it was important to get rid of the old-fashioned media and cultural segregations. So you are going to see what some call ethnographic material as well as photographs displayed alongside more traditional Western-style art objects. We are going to bring in a canoe, for example, and other symbolically powerful artifacts that help explain Canadian art history, things that you don’t normally associate with an art gallery.”
Mayer and his team also came to the conclusion that a complete redesign and reinstallation of the two galleries would be required. They commissioned internationally renowned museum designer Adrien Gardére, who was responsible for Toronto’s new Aga Khan Museum and other museums worldwide. “Adrien is one of the most sophisticated designers I have ever worked with. We have learned a lot from him,” said Mayer.
Part of what the team wrestled with is the tension inherent between the placement of art in the galleries. “Architecture should be of service to objects and not the other way around,” explained Mayer. “Rather than placing a painting in a room because that’s the only place it fits, we decided to open up the space and have floating walls. This will give us more freedom to tell the story the way in needs to be told.”
The new gallery will feel lighter and brighter, with the floors a paler hue and the rooms replete with new LED lighting, which allows for greater control as well as reducing energy use. The gallery is installing all new vitrines with a much finer glass, so viewers will be able to see through them unencumbered by distracting reflections and solid plinths.
Passionate about his work, Marc takes his responsibility for stewarding the past with the utmost seriousness. “Doctors take a Hippocratic oath and museum curators are like that too,” Mayer told me. “We see ourselves as stewards of the objects and we are obsessively loyal to them. No matter what culture made them, these objects have dignity, meaning, and power. Therefore, we want to make really sure that the way they are installed empowers them further.” To this end, Marc and his team are consulting with Indigenous experts on which objects should be included, how to display them correctly, and how to talk about them. The new signage will be in English, French and in the language of the objects’ makers. “For example, if a work of art was made by a Cree artist, the label will also be written in Cree,” said Mayer.
Mayer has also decided to break with traditional chronologies. The first room visitors enter will mix both historic and contemporary Indigenous works. “It’s important that we show that these ancient Canadian cultures are far from dead. In fact, they are thriving.” By showing the past and present together, Marc is taking another bold move. “This is very unusual and I hope it will provoke visitors into a new appreciation and understanding of not only First Nation art and artists but also the Canadian legacy.”
The National Gallery has a strong Canadian collection, but in the short term, to properly tell the story, material will have to be borrowed. “We are frantically sending out loan requests to the world. We don’t have much of a collection of Indigenous historical art. For example, our collection of Inuit art is only strong after 1950. Anything before that will have to come from other collections,” he confessed. “Also Metis flower beadwork. We own the beadwork-like painting by Christie Belcourt that couturier Valentino made famous but we haven’t collected actual Métis beadwork. It will take us years to build up that aspect of the collection.”
Christi Belcourt, Water Song, 2010-2011
Looking to the future, Mayer sees an opportunity to develop longer-term relationships. “A lot of material held by Canadian and foreign museums and galleries is sitting in storage due to lack of display space and also for conservation reasons. To solve our problem, we are working on building continuing relationships with different collections. In addition, we will slowly acquire exceptional things as they appear.”
The National Gallery’s newly renamed Canadian and Indigenous Galleries are only big enough to take viewers to about 1967. Consequently, for 2017, the curators for the Contemporary, Indigenous, and Photographs collections are cooperating on a temporary exhibition that will take visitors from 1967 to today.
With construction underway and staff working overtime, Marc is busy on the book that will accompany the exhibition. “It’s exciting to explore the grand themes of Canada’s fascinating art histories,” he said. “And you know, in many ways, it’s a thrilling and optimistic story, though for Indigenous artists, there were some long and very dark periods. We live in a different time now. Canada is no longer a European colony and institutionalized racism has subsided considerably. Our brilliantly diverse visual artists attest to our strength as a society every day. And they also alert us to the work that still remains to be done”
The new Canadian and Indigenous Galleries will open late May 2017.
The redesign is highlighting some of the National Gallery’s existing features. “We are opening up the walls on both sides of the Rideau Chapel so you will see it when you come to the arcade.” Photo Credit: National Gallery of Canada